Josh Allen Buffalo Bills
Home Latest NFL Quarterback Tiers for 2023

NFL Quarterback Tiers for 2023

227

There is no better time to start looking ahead to the 2023-2024 NFL season. In anticipation, we are releasing tier rankings for the offensive skill positions. To start, we will be focusing on the quarterback position. Below you will find our starting NFL quarterback tiers for the upcoming season. Before you look at our rankings, let’s point out some key highlights.

The Big Three

The ‘S’ tier is for the elite and that’s exactly what these three quarterbacks are. There isn’t much room to debate that Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow and Josh Allen are on another level. One could make an argument that Justin Herbert is sneaking into that conversation but he is not there yet.

Crowded B Tier

In all 13 quarterbacks made it into our ‘B’ tier. Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett just made it into this tier as the last quarterback selected. Pickett had a strong finish to his rookie season winning his last 3 starts. Expect him to get better in the Steelers offense as the year goes on.

One quarterback to watch in this list is Justin Fields. Fields carried the Chicago Bears offense for much of the 2022-2023 season. The key now will be if Fields can become a more complete quarterback. He will have a better receiving core with the addition of D.J. Moore and the offensive line is improved.

Started From the Bottom

As expected many of the rookie quarterbacks are in the ‘C’ and ‘D’ tiers. Anthony Richardson is still raw and will take some time to adjust to the NFL. Once he does, look out. He could quickly climb up these rankings as he is a dynamic playmaker. Fellow rookies C.J. Stroud and Bryce Young make it into the ‘C’ tier. At this point in time, they are more polished than Richardson and should be slated to start in week 1.

Colt McCoy made it into our tier list over Kyler Murray due to Murray’s injury. We already know Murray will miss the start of the 2023-2024 season with his ACL injury but it could be more than that. ACL injuries are tricky to navigate and it’s possible we won’t see Murray until the 2nd half of the season.

2023 NFL Quarterback Tiers
Click to enlarge
Written by
Justin Fuhr

Justin Fuhr is the owner of Pro Football Mania and a database engineer with experience building and maintaining data systems, performance models and analytical workflows. He created the PFM Team Score to compare NFL teams through quarterback stability, roster strength, coaching, recent performance, offense, defense and franchise direction.

Leave a comment

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments

PFM Data

PFM Rankings

Current leaders from the ProFootballMania ratings.

Related Articles

Five NFL teams to watch in 2026 training camp: Bears, Cowboys, Steelers, Panthers and Cardinals.
LatestNFLPFM Ratings

2026 NFL Training Camp: 5 Teams That Could Move Most in the PFM Rankings

PFM Training Camp Watch Training camp creates a lot of noise. One...

What is QB Stability
LatestNFLPFM Ratings

What Is QB Stability? A Deep Dive Into Our Quarterback Metric

The best quarterback is not always part of the most stable quarterback...

LatestNFLPFM Ratings

2025 PFM Team Score Accuracy: What We Got Right and Wrong

PFM Team Score Audit PFM ranked the Seahawks No. 1. Seattle won...

LatestNFLPFM Ratings

2026 NFL Hot Seat Rankings: Coaches Under Pressure

Not every NFL coach under pressure is one bad loss away from...