Home NFL Team Comparison
PFM TEAM COMPARISON

NFL Team Comparison Tool

Pick any two NFL teams to compare their PFM Team Score, overall ranking, quarterback stability, roster strength, coaching, offense, defense and franchise direction.

Select two teams below to see where each team has the edge.

Head-to-Head PFM Comparison

Major edgeKC

Kansas City Chiefs

87.1PFM Team Score#4 NFL
CLE

Cleveland Browns

71.4PFM Team Score#30 NFL
Quick Verdict

Patrick Mahomes is the biggest reason Kansas City gets the nod. The Chiefs have the best player at the most important position in this matchup.

Swap Teams Clear Comparison
HEAD-TO-HEAD PFM COMPARISON

Where Each Team Has the Edge

PFM Team Score

KC87.1
Kansas City Chiefs 87.1
CLE71.4
Cleveland Browns 71.4
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Overall NFL Rank

KC#4
Kansas City Chiefs #4
CLE#30
Cleveland Browns #30
Kansas City Chiefs ranks higher

QB Stability

KC86.2
Kansas City Chiefs 86.2
CLE67.0
Cleveland Browns 67.0
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Roster Strength

KC84.3
Kansas City Chiefs 84.3
CLE76.7
Cleveland Browns 76.7
Clear Kansas City Chiefs edge

Coaching Direction

KC92.3
Kansas City Chiefs 92.3
CLE73.0
Cleveland Browns 73.0
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Recent Performance

KC75.6
Kansas City Chiefs 75.6
CLE67.4
Cleveland Browns 67.4
Clear Kansas City Chiefs edge

Offense

KC83.2
Kansas City Chiefs 83.2
CLE69.5
Cleveland Browns 69.5
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Defense

KC83.8
Kansas City Chiefs 83.8
CLE84.2
Cleveland Browns 84.2
Slight Cleveland Browns edge

Franchise Direction

KC80.1
Kansas City Chiefs 80.1
CLE69.3
Cleveland Browns 69.3
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Explosiveness

KC80.0
Kansas City Chiefs 80.0
CLE63.7
Cleveland Browns 63.7
Major Kansas City Chiefs edge

Conference Rank

KC#1
Kansas City Chiefs #1
CLE#15
Cleveland Browns #15
Kansas City Chiefs ranks higher

Division Rank

KC#1
Kansas City Chiefs #1
CLE#4
Cleveland Browns #4
Kansas City Chiefs ranks higher

Outlook

KCSuper Bowl ContenderCLERebuilding or Major Concerns
Stronger outlook: Kansas City Chiefs
TEAM PROFILE

What Each Team Does Well and Where It Has Problems

Kansas City Chiefs

What Kansas City Does Best

Andy Reid has a clear idea of how Kansas City should play. The 92.3 Coaching Direction grade reflects a staff that consistently puts its best players in useful situations.

What Kansas City Needs to Fix

The 75.6 Recent Performance grade shows that Kansas City has not played to its talent. The team has been exposed in games where protection breaks down and Mahomes cannot use his normal movement to escape pressure.

Cleveland Browns

What Cleveland Does Best

Jared Verse gives Cleveland a defense that can take over stretches of a game. The 84.2 Defense grade belongs to a unit that can create stops without waiting for the offense to build a lead.

What Cleveland Needs to Fix

Cleveland is asking Jerry Jeudy to create too much the hard way. The 63.7 Explosiveness grade leaves the offense needing too many long drives to score.

PFM ANALYSIS

What the PFM Numbers Say

Kansas City's biggest advantage is simple: Patrick Mahomes is the more settled quarterback, while Cleveland is still figuring out who should run the offense. Kansas City also has more continuity on the sideline under Andy Reid. Todd Monken is just getting started in Cleveland.

Cleveland can make this a fight on defense, with Jared Verse leading the way. Even so, Kansas City has the better setup because its advantages at quarterback and on the sideline point in the same direction.

PFM ratings updated
How PFM grades NFL teams