Skip to content
Indianapolis Colts logo

Indianapolis Colts 2026 Team Rankings and Ratings

74.8PFM Team Score1-2 Record
PFM Verdict

Why PFM Ranks the Colts Here

Indianapolis keeps finding a way to stay in games and finish them. The Colts beat Houston 19-17 and held their PFM rank, but the narrow margin also explains why the overall score barely moved. Indianapolis is competitive enough to stay in the AFC South race, but the offense still needs more explosive production to create separation.

NFL Rank#26Current PFM ranking
AFC Rank#13Among AFC teams
QB Stability#25Daniel Jones · QB Limbo
Season OutlookPlayoff Long Shot
Head coachShane Steichen
Offensive coordinatorJim Bob Cooter
Defensive coordinatorLou Anarumo
Offense77.3No. 20
Defense73.9No. 29
Coaching Direction73.4No. 27
Latest Ratings Update

PFM Trend

Updated Sep 29, 2026
Latest directionImproved

Indianapolis gained slightly after a 19-17 win over Houston. Recent Performance and Defense Strength improved, while declines in the offensive and quarterback grades kept the increase modest.

PFM Team Score74.8
Score movement+0.11
NFL RankNo. 26
Rank movementNo rank change

PFM Score History

78 77 76 74 73 76.2 BASELINE 75.6 W1 74.7 W2 74.8 W3
Defense StrengthImproved72.6 → 73.9 · +1.36
Recent PerformanceImproved73.6 → 74.9 · +1.22
Offense StrengthDeclined78.4 → 77.3 · -1.11
PFM Team DNA

Indianapolis Colts Team DNA

View all NFL team rankings
Indianapolis Colts Team DNA chartPFM category scores on a 0 to 100 scale: QB Stability 76.5; Offense 77.3; Explosiveness 73.7; Roster Strength 74.8; Franchise Direction 72.8; Coaching Direction 73.4; Defense 73.9.
PFM category scores · 0–100 scale
QB Stability76.5No. 25 in NFLConcern
Offense77.3No. 20 in NFLConcern
Explosiveness73.7No. 23 in NFLMajor Concern
Roster Strength74.8No. 27 in NFLConcern
Franchise Direction72.8No. 27 in NFLMajor Concern
Coaching Direction73.4No. 27 in NFLMajor Concern
Defense73.9No. 29 in NFLMajor Concern
Identity

Offense Still Finding Its Way

Indianapolis wants Jonathan Taylor to set the terms, then let the passing game work off run action and manageable downs. The 19-17 win over Houston fit that identity, with the Colts staying patient and winning a game that never required the offense to become a high-volume passing attack.

Pressure Point

Indianapolis' Defense Has to Get Off the Field

Indianapolis has to replace the space Pierce creates even if no single receiver replaces his production. Without that vertical pull, defenses can crowd Taylor and squeeze the intermediate windows Jones needs to keep the offense on schedule.

PFM CALL Locks October 4th at 9:30 AM EDT

Who wins Indianapolis Colts vs. Washington Commanders?

Week 4 matchup
AwayIND1-2
HomeWSH1-2

Pick the winner.

Choose your Call
PFM ROAD AHEAD

2026 Indianapolis Colts Remaining Strength of Schedule

Indianapolis has one of the league’s more favorable remaining roads at No. 28, with opponents averaging 77.6. Minnesota Vikings, Jacksonville Jaguars and Dallas Cowboys still give the schedule a real test, but 3 games against current top-10 teams keep the full road from looking as heavy as most.

Difficulty Rank#28No. 1 is toughest
Remaining Opponent Avg.77.6Average across opponents
Next 3 Avg.76.2Upcoming opponents
Top-10 Matchups3Games vs. current top 10
Away games left7
Top-10 road opponents2

Toughest remaining opponent: Philadelphia Eagles at 84.7 PFM.

Around the League

League Context

Closest Team DNA Match

Built Like Atlanta Falcons

Atlanta Falcons logo
Atlanta FalconsMatch distance: 2.24 rating points

Shared profile: Offense and QB Stability.

Indianapolis supports the quarterback with a power run game and RPOs, while Atlanta gets there with the run game and play action. That means Indianapolis can stress the run fit before the throw, while Atlanta can pull linebackers toward the run before throwing behind them. The defensive gap favors Atlanta, with the stronger mix of rush and coverage built around pressure packages that change the protection.

Supporting Team Information

More About the Team

Badge History0 active badges

This team hasn't had an active badge yet.

Team Depth ChartStarters, backups and current roles

See the current Indianapolis Colts depth chart across offense, defense and special teams.

View Indianapolis Colts Depth Chart

Franchise History

Indianapolis Colts in the Super Bowl Era

Indianapolis has won 2 Super Bowls in 4 appearances, most recently Super Bowl XLI in 2007.

Super Bowl Titles
2
Super Bowl Appearances
4
Super Bowl Record
2–2
Last Appearance
2010 Super Bowl XLIV
View Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl History
PFM ratings updated
How PFM grades NFL teams