Skip to content
Pro Football Mania Pro Football Mania
New York Giants logoWashington Commanders logo

New York Giants vs. Washington Commanders: PFM Team Comparison

PFM rates the Washington Commanders higher than the New York Giants overall, with a clear advantage. The main reasons are the steadier quarterback room and the more dependable offense.

Current PFM Team Scores

NYG

New York Giants

73.3PFM Team Score#27 NFL
Clear edgeWSH

Washington Commanders

78.5PFM Team Score#18 NFL
WEEK 5 MATCHUP Sunday, Oct. 11 1:00 PM ET
View on NFL Schedule
PFM CALL Locks October 11th at 1:00 PM EDT

Who wins New York Giants vs. Washington Commanders?

Week 5 matchup
AwayNYG3-1
HomeWSH1-3

Pick the winner.

Choose your Call
Swap Teams Clear Comparison
PFM JUDGMENT

Why PFM Rates the Washington Commanders Higher

Quarterback is where the Washington Commanders have their cleanest advantage. With Jayden Daniels, the offense has a better floor when the first answer stops working. New York's strongest counterargument is Coaching Direction. The New York Giants have the stronger coaching operation under John Harbaugh. The advantage shows up in preparation, adjustments and pressure situations.

Washington also brings the more dependable offense. Washington adds the deeper roster. That is enough to keep the Washington Commanders ahead.

TEAM DNA COMPARISON

New York vs. Washington Across the Core Pillars

The farther a team reaches, the stronger the rating. Each category also calls out which team has the edge and the exact gap. Hover on desktop or tap on mobile to isolate one team.

NYGNew York Giants
WSHWashington Commanders
New York Giants vs. Washington Commanders Team DNA comparisonPFM category scores on a 0 to 100 scale. QB Stability: New York Giants 67.2, Washington Commanders 83.6, edge WSH +16.4; Offense: New York Giants 72.1, Washington Commanders 80.4, edge WSH +8.3; Defense: New York Giants 78.1, Washington Commanders 76.8, edge NYG +1.3; Coaching Direction: New York Giants 81.5, Washington Commanders 78.8, edge NYG +2.7; Roster Depth: New York Giants 73.4, Washington Commanders 78.6, edge WSH +5.2. Hover on desktop or tap on mobile to isolate one team at a time.
Hover or tap a team to focus that profile. Use Show Both to bring the overlay back.
THE COUNTERARGUMENT

New York Giants’ Best Argument

The staff edge favors the New York Giants. John Harbaugh gives the team steadier direction than Washington has on the sideline. That is why the overall gap is smaller than the score first suggests. Washington still answers with the steadier quarterback room and the more dependable offense, which keeps the overall judgment in place.

COMPLETE COMPARISON

Where Each Team Has the Edge

PFM Team Score

NYG73.3
New York Giants 73.3
WSH78.5
Washington Commanders 78.5
Clear Washington Commanders edge

Overall NFL Rank

NYG#27
New York Giants #27
WSH#18
Washington Commanders #18
Washington Commanders ranks higher

QB Stability

NYG67.2
New York Giants 67.2
WSH83.6
Washington Commanders 83.6
Major Washington Commanders edge

Roster Strength

NYG73.4
New York Giants 73.4
WSH78.6
Washington Commanders 78.6
Clear Washington Commanders edge

Coaching Direction

NYG81.5
New York Giants 81.5
WSH78.8
Washington Commanders 78.8
Clear New York Giants edge

Recent Performance

NYG76.7
New York Giants 76.7
WSH69.8
Washington Commanders 69.8
Clear New York Giants edge

Offense

NYG72.1
New York Giants 72.1
WSH80.4
Washington Commanders 80.4
Clear Washington Commanders edge

Defense

NYG78.1
New York Giants 78.1
WSH76.8
Washington Commanders 76.8
Slight New York Giants edge

Franchise Direction

NYG70.0
New York Giants 70.0
WSH77.6
Washington Commanders 77.6
Clear Washington Commanders edge

Explosiveness

NYG66.3
New York Giants 66.3
WSH74.7
Washington Commanders 74.7
Clear Washington Commanders edge

Conference Rank

NYG#14
New York Giants #14
WSH#9
Washington Commanders #9
Washington Commanders ranks higher

Division Rank

NYG#4
New York Giants #4
WSH#2
Washington Commanders #2
Washington Commanders ranks higher

Outlook

NYGPlayoff Long ShotWSHIn the Playoff Mix
Stronger outlook: Washington Commanders
SCHEDULE CONTEXT

Which Team Has the Tougher Road?

New York Giants

Remaining schedule rank: #12

Toughest stretch: Indianapolis Colts, San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks

Strongest opponents: Seattle Seahawks, San Francisco 49ers, Jacksonville Jaguars

Next five difficulty: 77.9

View New York Giants Road Ahead

Washington Commanders

Remaining schedule rank: #20

Toughest stretch: San Francisco 49ers, Philadelphia Eagles, Los Angeles Rams

Strongest opponents: San Francisco 49ers, Los Angeles Rams, Jacksonville Jaguars

Next five difficulty: 80.8

View Washington Commanders Road Ahead

New York has the tougher Road Ahead at No. 12. The strongest opponents include Seattle Seahawks, San Francisco 49ers, and Jacksonville Jaguars. Washington also has the more favorable road, which adds to the steadier quarterback room and the more dependable offense.

View the complete all-32 Road Ahead

Ratings and Schedule Freshness

PFM ratings updated October 6, 2026. Schedule data updated October 6, 2026.

How to Read This Comparison

PFM Team Score determines the overall order. The Team DNA comparison puts five core pillars on the same 0–100 scale, while the full rows show every current category.

PFM compares overall team strength rather than predicting one matchup. Road Ahead adds schedule context without changing PFM Team Score.

See the complete PFM NFL Team Rankings and methodology.

PFM ratings updated
How PFM grades NFL teams