Skip to content

New York Giants vs. Indianapolis Colts: PFM Team Comparison

PFM rates the New York Giants higher than the Indianapolis Colts overall, with a clear advantage. The main reasons are the stronger coaching operation and the steadier quarterback room.

Current PFM Team Scores

Clear edgeNYG

New York Giants

77.8PFM Team Score#17 NFL
IND

Indianapolis Colts

72.5PFM Team Score#30 NFL
HEAD-TO-HEAD RESULTS

New York Giants vs. Indianapolis Colts: Previous Meetings

Indianapolis Colts lead the recorded series 12–8 over 20 meetings.

New York Giants8 wins
Indianapolis Colts12 wins
Recorded meetings20

Regular season: 8–10–0  ·  Playoffs: 0–2–0 (New York Giants–Indianapolis Colts)

Recent Meetings

DateMatchupFinalWinner
Dec 29, 2024Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants33–45New York Giants
  1. Dec 29, 20242024 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway33 – 45New York GiantsHome
    New York Giants won
Earlier meetings (9)
DateMatchupFinalWinner
Jan 1, 2023Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants10–38New York Giants
Dec 23, 2018New York Giants at Indianapolis Colts27–28Indianapolis Colts
Nov 3, 2014Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants40–24Indianapolis Colts
Sep 19, 2010New York Giants at Indianapolis Colts14–38Indianapolis Colts
Sep 10, 2006Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants26–21Indianapolis Colts
Dec 22, 2002New York Giants at Indianapolis Colts44–27New York Giants
Nov 14, 1999Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants27–19Indianapolis Colts
Dec 12, 1993Indianapolis Colts at New York Giants6–20New York Giants
Nov 5, 1990New York Giants at Indianapolis Colts24–7New York Giants
  1. Jan 1, 20232022 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway10 – 38New York GiantsHome
    New York Giants won
  2. Dec 23, 20182018 season
    New York GiantsAway27 – 28Indianapolis ColtsHome
    Indianapolis Colts won
  3. Nov 3, 20142014 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway40 – 24New York GiantsHome
    Indianapolis Colts won
  4. Sep 19, 20102010 season
    New York GiantsAway14 – 38Indianapolis ColtsHome
    Indianapolis Colts won
  5. Sep 10, 20062006 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway26 – 21New York GiantsHome
    Indianapolis Colts won
  6. Dec 22, 20022002 season
    New York GiantsAway44 – 27Indianapolis ColtsHome
    New York Giants won
  7. Nov 14, 19991999 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway27 – 19New York GiantsHome
    Indianapolis Colts won
  8. Dec 12, 19931993 season
    Indianapolis ColtsAway6 – 20New York GiantsHome
    New York Giants won
  9. Nov 5, 19901990 season
    New York GiantsAway24 – 7Indianapolis ColtsHome
    New York Giants won
Swap Teams Clear Comparison
PFM JUDGMENT

Why PFM Rates the New York Giants Higher

John Harbaugh is the coaching difference. New York has the more dependable answers when the first answer stops working. Indianapolis' strongest counterargument is Franchise Direction. The long-term football direction favors the Indianapolis Colts only because New York carries the larger concern.

New York also brings the steadier quarterback room. New York adds the stronger defense. That is enough to keep the New York Giants ahead.

TEAM DNA COMPARISON

New York vs. Indianapolis Across the Core Pillars

The farther a team reaches, the stronger the rating. Each category also calls out which team has the edge and the exact gap. Hover on desktop or tap on mobile to isolate one team.

NYGNew York Giants
INDIndianapolis Colts
New York Giants vs. Indianapolis Colts Team DNA comparisonPFM category scores on a 0 to 100 scale. QB Stability: New York Giants 82.2, Indianapolis Colts 75.7, edge NYG +6.5; Offense: New York Giants 74.7, Indianapolis Colts 73.1, edge NYG +1.6; Defense: New York Giants 79.0, Indianapolis Colts 73.8, edge NYG +5.2; Coaching Direction: New York Giants 81.7, Indianapolis Colts 72.4, edge NYG +9.3; Roster Depth: New York Giants 72.6, Indianapolis Colts 74.5, edge IND +1.9. Hover on desktop or tap on mobile to isolate one team at a time.
Hover or tap a team to focus that profile. Use Show Both to bring the overlay back.
THE COUNTERARGUMENT

Indianapolis Colts’ Best Argument

The Indianapolis Colts have the clearer long-term football direction, although the grade remains a concern. That is why the overall gap is smaller than the score first suggests. New York still answers with the stronger coaching operation and the steadier quarterback room, which keeps the overall judgment in place.

COMPLETE COMPARISON

Where Each Team Has the Edge

PFM Team Score

NYG77.8
New York Giants 77.8
IND72.5
Indianapolis Colts 72.5
Clear New York Giants edge

Overall NFL Rank

NYG#17
New York Giants #17
IND#30
Indianapolis Colts #30
New York Giants ranks higher

QB Stability

NYG82.2
New York Giants 82.2
IND75.7
Indianapolis Colts 75.7
Clear New York Giants edge

Roster Strength

NYG72.6
New York Giants 72.6
IND74.5
Indianapolis Colts 74.5
Slight Indianapolis Colts edge

Coaching Direction

NYG81.7
New York Giants 81.7
IND72.4
Indianapolis Colts 72.4
Clear New York Giants edge

Recent Performance

NYG77.9
New York Giants 77.9
IND66.5
Indianapolis Colts 66.5
Major New York Giants edge

Offense

NYG74.7
New York Giants 74.7
IND73.1
Indianapolis Colts 73.1
Slight New York Giants edge

Defense

NYG79.0
New York Giants 79.0
IND73.8
Indianapolis Colts 73.8
Clear New York Giants edge

Franchise Direction

NYG70.1
New York Giants 70.1
IND73.0
Indianapolis Colts 73.0
Clear Indianapolis Colts edge

Explosiveness

NYG76.9
New York Giants 76.9
IND70.4
Indianapolis Colts 70.4
Clear New York Giants edge

Conference Rank

NYG#10
New York Giants #10
IND#15
Indianapolis Colts #15
New York Giants ranks higher

Division Rank

NYG#2
New York Giants #2
IND#3
Indianapolis Colts #3
New York Giants ranks higher

Outlook

NYGIn the Playoff MixINDPlayoff Long Shot
Stronger outlook: New York Giants
SCHEDULE CONTEXT

Which Team Has the Tougher Road?

New York Giants

Remaining schedule rank: #7

Toughest stretch: San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks, Cleveland Browns

Strongest opponents: San Francisco 49ers, Detroit Lions, Seattle Seahawks

Next five difficulty: 81.2

View New York Giants Road Ahead

Indianapolis Colts

Remaining schedule rank: #30

Toughest stretch: Cincinnati Bengals, Cleveland Browns, Jacksonville Jaguars

Strongest opponents: Jacksonville Jaguars, Cincinnati Bengals, New York Giants

Next five difficulty: 75.9

View Indianapolis Colts Road Ahead

New York has the tougher Road Ahead at No. 7. The strongest opponents include San Francisco 49ers, Detroit Lions, and Seattle Seahawks. Indianapolis gains one meaningful schedule advantage, while New York still owns the stronger football advantages elsewhere.

View the complete all-32 Road Ahead

Ratings and Schedule Freshness

PFM ratings updated November 17, 2026. Schedule data updated November 19, 2026.

How to Read This Comparison

PFM Team Score determines the overall order. The Team DNA comparison puts five core pillars on the same 0–100 scale, while the full rows show every current category.

PFM compares overall team strength rather than predicting one matchup. Road Ahead adds schedule context without changing PFM Team Score.

See the complete PFM NFL Team Rankings and methodology.

Historical results: sources and coverage

Results shown: 1954–2024.

Historical scores: FiveThirtyEight (CC BY 4.0). Scores since 1999: nflverse (CC BY 4.0). Earlier meetings that have not been verified are excluded.

PFM ratings updated
How PFM grades NFL teams