Home NFL Team Comparison
PFM TEAM COMPARISON

NFL Team Comparison Tool

Pick any two NFL teams to compare their PFM Team Score, overall ranking, quarterback stability, roster strength, coaching, offense, defense and franchise direction.

Select two teams below to see where each team has the edge.

Head-to-Head PFM Comparison

NO

New Orleans Saints

70.6PFM Team Score#32 NFL
Slight edgeCAR

Carolina Panthers

72.5PFM Team Score#29 NFL
Quick Verdict

Bryce Young is the biggest reason Carolina gets the nod. The Panthers have the best player at the most important position in this matchup.

Swap Teams Clear Comparison
HEAD-TO-HEAD PFM COMPARISON

Where Each Team Has the Edge

PFM Team Score

NO70.6
New Orleans Saints 70.6
CAR72.5
Carolina Panthers 72.5
Slight Carolina Panthers edge

Overall NFL Rank

NO#32
New Orleans Saints #32
CAR#29
Carolina Panthers #29
Carolina Panthers ranks higher

QB Stability

NO69.2
New Orleans Saints 69.2
CAR75.1
Carolina Panthers 75.1
Clear Carolina Panthers edge

Roster Strength

NO71.9
New Orleans Saints 71.9
CAR70.9
Carolina Panthers 70.9
Slight New Orleans Saints edge

Coaching Direction

NO72.0
New Orleans Saints 72.0
CAR70.8
Carolina Panthers 70.8
Slight New Orleans Saints edge

Recent Performance

NO71.5
New Orleans Saints 71.5
CAR74.0
Carolina Panthers 74.0
Clear Carolina Panthers edge

Offense

NO69.0
New Orleans Saints 69.0
CAR72.9
Carolina Panthers 72.9
Clear Carolina Panthers edge

Defense

NO78.1
New Orleans Saints 78.1
CAR74.6
Carolina Panthers 74.6
Clear New Orleans Saints edge

Franchise Direction

NO66.1
New Orleans Saints 66.1
CAR71.8
Carolina Panthers 71.8
Clear Carolina Panthers edge

Explosiveness

NO61.1
New Orleans Saints 61.1
CAR71.8
Carolina Panthers 71.8
Major Carolina Panthers edge

Conference Rank

NO#16
New Orleans Saints #16
CAR#15
Carolina Panthers #15
Carolina Panthers ranks higher

Division Rank

NO#4
New Orleans Saints #4
CAR#3
Carolina Panthers #3
Carolina Panthers ranks higher

Outlook

NORebuilding or Major ConcernsCARNeeds More Help
Stronger outlook: Carolina Panthers
TEAM PROFILE

What Each Team Does Well and Where It Has Problems

New Orleans Saints

What New Orleans Has Going for It

Carl Granderson gives New Orleans a defense it can lean on, but the 78.1 grade is not dominant. The unit still has to finish more drives with a stop.

What New Orleans Needs to Fix

New Orleans is asking Chris Olave to create too much the hard way. The 61.1 Explosiveness grade leaves the offense needing too many long drives to score.

Carolina Panthers

Carolina's Best Grade

Carolina does not have a true strength in the current ratings. QB Stability leads the team at 75.1, but Bryce Young still needs a better setup around him.

What Carolina Needs to Fix

Dave Canales has to give Carolina better answers when Young has to carry the offense without help from the run game. The 70.8 Coaching Direction grade points to a staff that still needs more consistency in preparation and adjustments.

PFM ANALYSIS

What the PFM Numbers Say

Bryce Young is the better quarterback in this matchup. He gives Carolina more when the pocket breaks down than Tyler Shough gives New Orleans. The big-play numbers tell the same story. Carolina leads Explosiveness by 10.7 points and creates quick points more often.

New Orleans can make this a fight on defense, with Carl Granderson leading the way. Even so, Carolina has the better setup because its advantages at quarterback and in big-play ability point in the same direction.

PFM ratings updated
How PFM grades NFL teams